A Redeemed cynic, class of 2012

I think I’m supposed to say something inspiring here, something that causes thought and provokes discussion, in essence, a virtual “pat on the back” for not only the Institution that birthed my educational awakening, but also the students that will follow after me.

This opinion piece will do neither of those things. Just so you’re prepared.

I avoid writing opinion pieces when I can help it, although over the last semester it’s happened more than I would like. The act of concretely laying out my arguments on paper, then publishing them for public critique and mockery, makes a small part of me wish to run and hide. As the editor of the opinion page, this is not usually an option.

While at Indiana Wesleyan University, I have whole heartedly realized that I’m not an expert in anything. While I may have opinions, they are neither educated enough nor well formed enough to merit true pride, let alone publication, save one thing. In a generation of social-media obsessed narcissists, I do have monopoly on being an expert on myself. Some of what I’ve learned in that status while at this university, however, I would prefer not to know.

I’m thankful for the way my time here has changed me, the lessons I’ve learned and the issues I’ve struggled over. The challenges and victories have made me a better thinker, a well-rounded person, and hopefully, an interesting conversationalist and writer. As a side effect of study, however, I picked up a nasty personal habit: cynicism.

My mother tells me I’m too young to be a cynic. She’s always frustratingly optimistic, a characteristic I once shared. I’m not sure where I deviated from a much brighter, “sunny side” way of thinking, but it happened. For the past few years (as I grew aware of my shift in viewpoint) I may have denied it, then simply blamed the shift on my subjects of study. Journalism and political science are not exactly optimistic fields. My conversations have increasingly become focused on what I’m frustrated about in the world, and of late, what frustrates me about this university, my university.

As I pursue life after IWU I have a choice. I can choose, based on the evidence I’ll surely find around me, that life is best handled through realism, exemplified in cynicism. Or, I can choose to take what I discover and continue to look for the positive aspect of any circumstance … because there always is one.

I realize that I’m not the first to suggest that an optimistic, positive viewpoint may be helpful. (I refer to my previous statement highlighting my inadequacies in writing opinion pieces.) It sounds terribly cheesy, after all, to think that “looking on the bright side” will make a difference, even change your life.

That’s not what I’m saying. I’m saying that I need to stop pretending that cynicism is an inevitable and healthy part of life. For me, it hasn’t been healthy. It’s caused me to rant about things that don’t ultimately matter to the people who tirelessly love me, it’s resulted in my judgment of others (both those in authority in my life as well as my peers), and it’s caused me to view aspects of my university, my faith and my fellow human beings with skepticism, if not disdain.

While that type of cynicism may indeed represent how the world functions, I can’t see that ultimately, it’s going to do me any good.

Currently, I’d classify myself as a “redeemed cynic.” It’s something God and I have talked about and he’s turned into a beautiful part of my personality, instead of a black hole of negativity. But note the fact that it’s still part of my identity. In the end, I’m still very critical of the things that go on around me. I still struggle with judgment. And, I have an even harder time curbing my comments, witty or not, when I should probably find other things to occupy my mind.

Somewhere, there’s a happy medium, a balance between obnoxious idealism and hardened cynicism. To all of you who follow after all of us: Find that balance before you leave. The world is cynical enough already.

Posted in FeaturesComments (0)

Honoring Cameron: First to receive Presidential Citation

For the past eight years, each audience at the Society of World Changers inductions has watched as showcased individuals received honorary doctorates after being awarded the title “World Changer.”

During the ninth annual ceremony, honoring actor Kirk Cameron, however, an audience at Indiana Wesleyan University’s main campus saw for the first time the awarding of a presidential citation.

Cameron is the first inductee of the Society of World Changers to receive a presidential citation in lieu of an honorary doctorate, according to Dr. Larry Lindsey, chief of staff.

While still a high honor, the presidential citation is fundamentally different than an honorary doctorate.

“Honorary doctorates are very special recognitions. It’s the highest honor we could give to someone outside of them being a student,” said Dr. Mike Fratzke, chair of the Division of Health and Human Performance.

Fratzke serves as one of two faculty senate representatives on the University Honorary Degrees Council, which assesses and determines the awarding of honorary doctorates from IWU.

The qualifications for such an honor are not fixed.

“There aren’t any written guidelines that are in our faculty handbook that tell us specifically when to do one or you do the other,” said Dr. David Wright, provost and chief academic officer. “So it has to deal really with a bit of a judgment call that unfolds as you consider the individual and what they’ve done or where they are in their life and in their careers.”

In general, however, when considering awarding an individual with an honorary doctorate, areas of assessment include the person’s “level of achievement, length of achievement and breadth of influence within a professional career,” according to Wright.

Additionally, non-academic factors are of influence.

“As a Christian university, one of the things we look for is their commitment to Christ, their focus on that in their life,” said Fratzke.

Additionally, according to Wright, a significant difference between an honorary doctorate and a presidential citation comes from the source of the award.

“The president can give a citation to honor somebody for whatever they’ve done that is worthy of honor. And that really, that ability is vested in the president’s office,” said Wright. “A doctorate, on the other hand … presidents don’t give doctorates, the institution gives doctorates.”

According to Fratzke, Cameron was not presented to the University Honorary Degrees Council as a candidate for potentially receiving an honorary doctorate.

“We didn’t have it as a committee issue, but I would assume Kirk maybe didn’t have some of the same academic credentials in the academic field that might work toward him being considered for a doctorate. His name has not come to our committee,” Fratzke said.

According to Wright, the president and his office are responsible for determining the awarding of a presidential citation, independent of the review of the Honorary Degrees Council.


Related Stories:
Honoring Cameron: 2012 World Changer inducted
Honoring Cameron: student perspectives

Posted in Front Page, News, On CampusComments (0)

Crisis diplomacy: Model UN to compete in Chicago

Honorable administrators and fellow students,

The delegates of Indiana Wesleyan University’s Model United Nations club believe that understanding the topics of international affairs and world politics is essential to the IWU community. These issues are central to all majors, not simply those within political science or international relations. Through attending the 15th annual MUN competition in Chicago, Ill., April 5-8, MUNIWU looks forward to establishing resolutions on international conflict through intentional dialogue surrounding issues relevant to the IWU campus and the world. Thank you.

Guided by the established principles of Model UN,

Model United Nations is a hybrid of debate, role-playing, current events, problem-solving and teamwork. All extra-curricular, of course.

A concept that originated in Ivy League schools, Model UN clubs come together annually at numerous international conferences with one goal in mind: resolution through simulating work done in the United Nations.

“Model UN was created to be able to kind of show a reflection of how the UN works, and give students a chance to be able to engage in that and feel like they have a greater role in the world,” said Laurel Stone (sr), secretary general of MUNIWU.

MUNIWU will compete at the 2012 Chicago Model UN conference over Easter weekend, when student delegates will take on international “characters” they will portray throughout the conference weekend, making decisions and engaging in committees as the individuals they represent.

“You’re not supposed to break character. So at times, you feel like you’re in an acting class, which is kind of funny,” Stone said. “But it helps you see from their perspective, and that whole time it’s your job to maintain that person’s point of view.”

Having considered the implications of international crises.

As students engage in diplomacy, they will experience crisis “simulations” reflecting a variety of made-up, historical and modern-day conflicts, an exhilarating but daunting experience, according to Matt Eckhardt (fr).

“What will happen in the middle of the thing is ‘this country declared war on another country.’ All of the sudden, out of the blue. What do you do? And you’ve got to know who’s side you’re on, how your country would react ideally in the situation, who your friends are and then basically, go off of that. So it’s kind of jumping into a situation, but there’s a lot of fun in that also,” Eckhardt said.

During the conference, participants will be asked to present opening statements, engage in structured debates and draft resolutions, all using Parliamentary Procedure, a system of law for organizing formal meetings and structuring official documents. All delegate activities aim to provide solutions for the problems created during the crisis simulation

“They’ll constantly throw things at you, and they’ll kind of manipulate it, so that if you start getting toward a resolution, all of the sudden there might be some crisis, and they’ll pin two people directly against each other and so you have to figure out what to do in the midst of that,” Stone said.

During Stone’s first experience with Model UN at the 2009 Chicago conference, she encountered the drama and excitement that come from participating in a crisis simulation.

“We had people dress up to fit the roles. We had hostage situations where they came in with airsoft guns and they had masks on and everything, and they were like kidnapping someone, abducting them,” Stone said.

During one of her committee sessions, Stone was nearly “assassinated.”

“I had to talk my way out of it,” Stone said. “Venezuela got me. I don’t know how.”

1. Expresses its appreciation of new participants in the work of the United Nations;

For the 2012 Chicago conference, IWU delegates will participate as members of the International community in a variety of committees. Less than one month ago, after applying for admittance to the conference, MUNIWU delegates were assigned characters to portray from within the CIA, the Republican party, the Department of Treasury, the Cabinet of Bolivia and the UN mission in Sudan, in addition to others. Most of the characters are based on real people.

Although delegates are provided with information concerning the issues of their committee and the background of their character, much of what happens during the conference requires quick thinking instead of preparation.

“We know the general area of where this could take place, but till we get there, we don’t know what our debate will actually be about. So we study the most general, broad stuff that we possibly can and pray and hope that we’re actually getting something done in the process,” Eckhardt said.

Only two of this year’s MUNIWU team members have previously participated in a MUN conference.

Stone, the club’s only senior, was left with lone experienced upperclassman Janelle Hankins (jr) after most of the previous officers of the club graduated last year. To create a team to compete at the conference, Stone began recruiting underclassmen. Of the 12 current members, eight are freshman and one is a sophomore.

The inclusion of so many young members directly influenced Stone’s leadership strategy for this year.

“I’ve been trying to do as much of a holistic approach as I have the capacity to be able to do, so they are stretched intellectually as well as just emotionally and even just out of their comfort bounds. I’ve been trying to push them out slowly … and then make them jump off a cliff,” Stone said, smiling wryly.

For freshman members, weekly MUN meetings and group discussions have helped to inform and inspire them to understand international issues.

“There is a lot of things that I’ve learned being in the club of international issues that I had absolutely no idea of before, even from taking classes, that I didn’t know about,” said Rachel Abrego (fr).

For Gabrielle Crofford (jr), also a first-year member, the club’s youth is a strength.

“I think the main strength is to prove that anybody can do it. We have people sitting here that weren’t even interested in this sort of stuff at the beginning of the year, but because Laurel went and recruited them, they at least had enough interest to then be a part and get roped into all the fun,” Crofford said.

Those with experience are pleased with the new members’ performance.

“They are perfectly competent, very capable people and very intelligent, all of them,” said Stone.

“I am just so blown away, pleased, pleasantly surprised at how well they’ve adapted, how much they’ve been able to soak in and how professional they sound when they go about something that it’s true, they have just started to learn,” Hankins said.

2. Reaffirms MUNIWU’s foundation;

IWU’s Model UN club was formed just four years ago as part of a class project. In fall 2007, then-freshmen Lisa Massey, Derek Freds and Ben Zendejas (alumni ‘11), took a class in world politics with Kris Pence, assistant professor of political science. Pence gave the students the opportunity to “diplomatically” suggest and complete an alternative assignment to a research paper. Massey, Freds and Zendejas chose to draft the constitution for IWU’s Model UN club, which had its first official meeting in fall 2008.

“I’m really glad that someone actually took the first step to start this club because it is a thing where we all hear about the IWU bubble. It’s just something that keeps us from being engaged in the community, and it’s really just an idea,” said Luke Smith (fr), MUNIWU’s secretary general for next year. “The IWU bubble really isn’t a real thing. It’s really just a perception that people have.”

3. Calls upon the IWU community to take action.

As Stone prepares to pass on the secretary general position to Smith, she expresses high hopes for the club.

“I want them to know that they can achieve anything they want,” Stone said. “I’m really hoping that they can kind of take different things that they can do on campus and be a presence on campus, not just at a conference, and be able to find a balance between having fun, but also being realistic about this stuff and being able to educate people too and inform.”

Understanding the issues that MUNIWU evaluates is closely related to the mission of Indiana Wesleyan University.

“Our school talks about world changers with a passion, and to actually understand that world and to actually be able to help it are two completely different things,” said Paul McCraken (fr).

By increasing participation in the club, MUNIWU members hope to increase the IWU community’s ability to understand and make a difference in the world.

“We’re looking for anyone who’s really interested in the world and that’s really willing to put the work in,” said Smith. “This is still a mock, kind-of-pretend way to get involved, but it’s still learning how to practically, just at the ground level, see how people are writing resolutions that are actually going to action. We just want motivated people. I think that’s all you need is motivation.”

Posted in Front Page, News, On CampusComments (0)

World Changer nominations encouraged: response to alumnus petition

Students, faculty and staff are now invited to submit nominations for future World Changers after extensive conversation surrounded the upcoming induction of actor/evangelist Kirk Cameron into The Society of World Changers.

Nominations from the Indiana Wesleyan University community can be sent via email to Dr. Larry Lindsay, chief of staff and a member of the World Changers selection committee, according to Janelle Vernon, associate vice president for marketing and communications.

Previously, the selection for the annual honor was exclusively determined by a committee of six members, including Lindsay, Dr. Henry Smith, president, and Dr. Jim Lo, dean of the chapel.

The change in the nomination process comes after a number of people connected with IWU stated their support for a petition questioning the decision to induct Cameron. Created by Eric Nentrup (alumnus ‘98) on March 12, the online petition currently has more than 300 signatures.

As of March 27, of the 321 signatures, 89 belonged to students, three to IWU employees, 11 to alumni and 152 did not claim affiliation with the university (nor are they students or faculty). Forty-six were signed anonymously or with only first names and the remaining 20 were duplicates.

The IWU campus appears deeply divided over the choice of Cameron. The Sojourn launched an informal Facebook poll March 25 that obtained 169 votes, 73 of which were in favor of Cameron’s induction, 64 of which were opposed. The remaining 32 respondents indicated either that they didn’t care or that the decision was not theirs to make.

Some of those pro-Cameron students have made comments on the Sojourn website.

Justin Tracy (so), in response to Nentrup’s letter to the editor from March 22, wrote, “I will say this; I am in the small minority of those who are not calling for the reversal of this decision to include Mr. Cameron as a World Changer this semester. I have great respect for the accomplishments he has achieved both in film and on television with Mr. Ray Comfort. Do I agree with 100% of the things said or methods taken, no. Overall though, I feel that to have Mr. Cameron inducted as a World Changer at IWU is a good thing and hearing all the negative associations that many the student body have stated is a little disappointing and saddening.”

The petition’s open letter, addressed to “Dr. Smith and the Board of Directors,” is titled “Indiana Wesleyan University cheapened by Kirk Cameron.”

After the petition appeared online, The Sojourn was contacted by Nentrup and published the open letter, with his permission, on March 21.

“My number one intent for this was to speak up about an issue that I felt needed further attention by the school leadership and what I discovered is that it wasn’t about launching a campaign against Kirk Cameron or so much throwing stones at the administration of Indiana Wesleyan University,” said Nentrup in an interview. “It was about realizing that as an alumni, I have an obligation to help protect the university even from itself.”

Current IWU students responded to Nentrup’s petition, some through simply signing their names, but others through comments stating their personal positions.

Evan Doyle (jr), who signed the petition March 13, appreciated that the petition was the work of an individual from outside the IWU campus.

“There have been petitions about it in the past, but really I felt like this had some more legitimacy to it because of the alumni involvement,” Doyle said.

As an alumnus, Nentrup felt he was particularly affected by the university’s choice.

“If you live in central Indiana, which I do, the growth and influence of Indiana Wesleyan University is readily apparent. You don’t have to be an alumnus to know about it, you just have to drive on I-465 to witness it. So that raises the stakes for those of us who have matriculated through Indiana Wesleyan a decade, 20, 30 years ago,” Nentrup said.

According to Vernon, the administration at IWU is aware of Nentrup’s open letter and the resulting petition.

“I know that this conversation has been shared with the administration and that they are aware of it and are very interested and appreciative of all the opinions that are being brought forward,” Vernon said.

According to Vernon, the perspectives addressed in both the petition and its comments are part of the larger dialogue for those within and connected to IWU, a dialogue that includes a significant number of people sharing Cameron’s beliefs and expressing support for those who chose to select him as 2012 World Changer.

“Would this be seen as appropriate conversation?” Vernon asked. “Absolutely. We are a community, and communities have opinions.”

Josh Landers (jr), who signed the petition March 13, experienced a shift in his opinions concerning the university’s choice of Cameron.

“I heard a lot of people who were just really negatively attacking the guy and saying, ‘Oh, he’s a horrible choice,’ and I was kind of turned off of that. Because I thought it sounded really whiny and it sounded really negative,” Landers said.

The comments after Nentrup’s open letter made Landers reconsider.

“I read the petition, and I read the things that people were saying and reading the way people were wording it,” Landers said. “I thought, ‘OK, now I see what you’re saying, and I can agree with you.’ And some of the arguments were good enough that I kind of changed my mind.”

IWU chose Kirk Cameron as the 2012 World Changer in 2009, according to Vernon.

According to Vernon, selecting a World Changer candidate is based on the individual’s faith, in addition to his or her accomplishments.

“The decisions are made with the goal of honoring the individual and maintaining the mission and the ministry of the institution,” Vernon said.

For Nentrup, IWU’s selection of Cameron directly conflicts with such goals, although Nentrup hopes to continue to have pride in his alma mater.

“What I’m afraid of is that, with Indiana Wesleyan’s growth over the last decade or so, their ability to remain relevant and remember what their prime objective is,” said Nentrup, “may not be reflected in their choice to recognize someone such as Kirk Cameron.”

The annual world changer award is based on a concept put forth in the book “Roaring Lambs” by author Bob Briner, the first-ever inductee into The Society of World Changers.

After graduating, Nentrup was employed in IWU’s University Advancement Office during the same year former IWU President Jim Barnes encountered “Roaring Lambs.”

“It seems like a huge risk to take, bestowing upon anybody who’s still alive, regardless of what their accomplishments have been, it seems like a huge risk to take not knowing the full extent of what that person is going to contribute to the world at large,” Nentrup said. “And that to me seems like a big departure from the kind of case study that Bob Briner pointed out in his book, ‘Roaring Lambs,’ if I remember correctly.”

For Doyle and Landers, the decision to sign Nentrup’s petition came not from a direct critique of Cameron himself, but concerns with the process of selecting a World Changer candidate.

“The reason I signed is different from the reason why I disagree with the choice,” Landers said. “The reason I signed is because I think students’ and faculty’s voices need to be heard on the issue.”

“I think the criteria they have in place are good. I just think we have to make sure that those criteria are upheld,” Doyle said.

According to Vernon, the ability for the IWU community to submit nominations for future World Changers will help to improve the selection process.

In reflection of this, IWU alumna Cheryl Beckett, killed in Afghanistan in 2011, will be inducted as the first alumni World Changer in Fall 2012.

Nentrup said he plans to formally submit his letter to the president and the Board of Directors in the near future.

“I feel an obligation to finish what I started,” Nentrup said.

Posted in News, On CampusComments (0)

advert